AI Expired Listing Prompts for Real Estate Agents
Expired listings represent motivated sellers who still want to sell — they just had a bad experience. These AI prompts help you approach them with empathy, a fresh marketing plan, and a clear value proposition that differentiates you from their previous agent.
Advertisement
1. Initial Outreach Email to Expired Listing Owner
Write a first-contact email to a homeowner whose listing just expired.
Details:
- Homeowner name: Karen
- Property: 456 Elm Street, Austin TX — 4bed/2.5bath, was listed at $525,000 for 120 days
- Market context: Similar homes in the area are selling in 25-30 days at $480K-$510K. The listing may have been overpriced and had limited online marketing presence.
- My name: Sarah Johnson, Premier Realty
Requirements:
- Acknowledge their frustration without criticizing the previous agent
- Show that I've researched their property specifically (not a mass email)
- Identify 1-2 likely reasons it didn't sell (tactfully — based on market data, not blame)
- Briefly outline what I would do differently
- Offer a free, no-obligation consultation
- Empathetic, professional, confident — never desperate
- Under 150 words
- 3 subject line options
2. "What I'd Do Differently" Marketing Plan
Create a brief marketing plan I can present to an expired listing owner showing what I'd do differently to sell their home.
Property: 456 Elm Street, Austin TX — 4bed/2.5bath, previously listed at $525,000 for 120 days
Previous listing issues I noticed: only 8 photos (low quality, no twilight shots), no virtual tour, generic listing description, no social media marketing visible, priced $25K above comparable sales
My marketing plan should cover:
1. PRICING STRATEGY — data-driven pricing approach and recommended price
2. PHOTOGRAPHY & PRESENTATION — what I'd upgrade (professional photos, virtual tour, staging)
3. DIGITAL MARKETING — social media, targeted ads, email marketing to buyer database
4. MLS & SYNDICATION — optimized listing remarks, enhanced syndication
5. OPEN HOUSE STRATEGY — event-based open house plan
6. TIMELINE — realistic timeline and milestones
7. MY TRACK RECORD — brief stats (avg DOM, sale-to-list ratio, homes sold)
Format as a clean, professional one-page document. Under 400 words. Each section: bold heading + 2-3 bullet points. End with a CTA to schedule a listing appointment.
3. Expired Listing Phone Script
Write a phone script for calling an expired listing homeowner on the day their listing expires.
My name: Sarah Johnson
Their property: expired today, was on market for 90+ days
Script sections:
1. OPENING (15 sec): Introduce myself, acknowledge the situation with empathy, ask permission to talk briefly
2. DISCOVERY (45 sec): 3 questions to understand their feelings, timeline, and what happened
- "Are you still looking to sell?"
- "What do you think prevented it from selling?"
- "What would you want done differently next time?"
3. VALUE BRIDGE (30 sec): Connect their answers to my specific approach
4. CLOSE (15 sec): Offer a free in-home consultation with a personalized marketing plan
Objection responses for:
- "I'm taking a break from selling"
- "I'm going to try another agent my friend recommended"
- "I'm going to try FSBO next"
- "I'm not changing the price"
Requirements:
- Empathetic, not aggressive — they've had a bad experience
- Ask more questions than make statements
- Never badmouth the previous agent
- Under 250 words for the main script
Advertisement
4. Expired Listing Follow-Up Sequence (4 emails)
Create a 4-email follow-up sequence for an expired listing homeowner who didn't respond to my initial outreach.
My name: Sarah Johnson, Premier Realty
Their situation: Home expired after 90+ days, likely frustrated
Sequence:
1. DAY 3 — Market insight: Share a relevant market data point for their neighborhood (new comp that sold, inventory change)
2. DAY 7 — Success story: Brief story of a similar expired listing I successfully sold (or would sell — modify accordingly)
3. DAY 14 — Value add: Offer a free home valuation or market report for their neighborhood
4. DAY 21 — Soft close: Final gentle touch, standing offer for a consultation, wish them well
Each email:
- Subject line
- Under 80 words
- Different value proposition each time
- Never mention the expired listing directly after the first email
- Build trust, not urgency
- Professional, empathetic tone
5. Handwritten Note / Personal Letter
Write a short, personal note to hand-deliver or mail to an expired listing homeowner.
My name: Sarah Johnson
Their property: 456 Elm Street — beautiful home that expired after 120 days
Something specific I noticed: The home has a gorgeous backyard with mature trees that wasn't featured prominently in the previous listing photos
Requirements:
- Handwritten note style (short, personal, not corporate)
- Under 60 words
- One genuine compliment about their home
- One observation about what could be done differently (positive framing)
- Soft invitation to chat
- Include my phone number
- Warm and genuine — this should feel like it came from a real person who cares
Expired Listing Outreach Tips
- Speed matters — Contact expired listings within 24 hours; they get bombarded by agents quickly
- Research first — Always look at the expired listing before reaching out; reference specific details
- Lead with empathy — They're frustrated. Acknowledge that before pitching anything.
- Never criticize the previous agent — Focus on what you'll do, not what they did wrong
- Have a specific plan — Vague promises won't work; show a concrete, different marketing approach
- Multi-channel outreach — Combine email + phone + personal note for maximum impact
- Track everything in your CRM — CRM tools help manage follow-up sequences
Personalize Every Expired Listing Outreach
ChatGPT generates customized outreach for each expired listing in seconds. No more generic templates.
Affiliate links. Learn more.